Mark 2:23-28
The Stealers of Joy
Was Jesus a liberal?
Who decides what is lawful?
Do you pick at people who don’t follow your rules?
A basic analysis of the text.
The ambiguity: Using the notion of “being right” while stealing the joy of others.
The analysis: What motivates us to act in such ways?
The Key: Not losing sight of Jesus in the discussion.
The gospel: Is the gospel an invitation to misery or joy. Not that we are excluded from miseries in a fallen world but that we experience joy in midst of fallenness.
The consequences: Appreciate the freedom that other thinking Christians have to figure out what it means to walk with Jesus.
Introduction:
Let’s think today about two people. I’ll call them, Mr. and Mrs. Right – RIGHT is “the ideal of moral propriety.” Mr. and Mrs. Right are pretty easy to identify because they are always right. They wear the right clothes; they listen to the right music; they have the right theology; they belong to the right political party; they’re happy to be a member of the right race. Mr. and Mrs. Right were born at the right time and in the right place. They have the right life-style. They only choose the right things in life. The world is blessed because they are right.
Mr. Right says to a teen that has given testimony of a wonderful experience at camp, “yes, that’s nice but you’ll come back to the real world.” Or, “let’s see if you live up to it.” (To my regret that I have done that!)
Mrs. Right takes a child’s report card of “A’s”, “B’s”, and “C’s” and points out only the “C’s”? (I regret that I’ve done that!)
There’s nothing like having the joy of preaching a great sermon (that happens once in a while) only to be met by Mr. Right with a disagreement over a minor theological point. He’s right! (I’ve done that!)
Mr. Right comes home from work each day only noticing the toys not put away, and dust on the piano, missing the smile of children and the eyes of a wife looking for affirmation? He’s right!
Who hasn’t had those moments of great joy stolen away by inconsiderate and sometimes malicious judgments by Mr. or Mrs. Right? My first inclination is that I want to stone Mr. and Mrs. Right! Then I’m reminded that at times I am Mr. Right!
Everyone one of us has lived those moments when we are the thieves who steal away the joy of others? Mr. and Mrs. Right live within each of us.
Listen to our text:
Mark 2:23-28 23 ¶ One Sabbath he was going through the grainfields, and as they made their way, his disciples began to pluck heads of grain. 24 And the Pharisees were saying to him, “Look, why are they doing what is not lawful on the Sabbath?” 25 And he said to them, “Have you never read what David did, when he was in need and was hungry, he and those who were with him: 26 how he entered the house of God, in the time of Abiathar the high priest, and ate the bread of the Presence, which it is not lawful for any but the priests to eat, and also gave it to those who were with him?” 27 And he said to them, “The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath. 28 So the Son of Man is lord even of the Sabbath.”
Imagine this leisurely stroll through the wheat fields with Jesus on a sunny Sabbath in Galilee. The Sabbath was Israel’s day of rest and a time for reflection on God’s creation and His redemption. It was a day for joy and removal from the pressing obligations of six days of work.
This moment with Jesus is one of those rare carefree times to simply enjoy the walk and the world. As they walk, they pluck and eat the ripened wheat. They savor the moment, tasting fresh grain, leisurely strolling, and being with Jesus.
The Pharisees speak. Their words are like a thunderstorm on a quiet autumn beach. Their accusation rings like that annoying wrong number at 2:00 in the morning when you’ve just reached a point of deep sleep.
The silence and quietude is broken - ”Look, why are they doing what is unlawful on the Sabbath?” Suddenly, the wheat on the tongue no longer draws saliva. The sun seems to dim; legs labor to move on. The joy of that moment is swept away by the cloudburst of criticism.
Mr. Right has appeared to spoil the day. The Pharisees had been spying. They were certain that anyone who was having a good time must have been doing something wrong.
If a group of teens are huddled together laughing, it must be risqué.
If a guy and girl want to be alone, they must have sex in mind.
If alternative Christian music creates such celebration, it can’t be Christian.
If they dance at a wedding, they must be worldly.
If they look like they have a really good marriage, they must be hiding something.
If they enjoy a glass of wine, they must be drunkards.
I spoke with a woman one day who is married to a Pharisee (yes, Pharisees still live in the 21st Century). The Pharisee husband determines the movies she watches. He insists that she read only the KJV. She cannot listen to contemporary Christian music. He forbids her to have a glass of wine with her Italian dinner. He is quick to remind her that he is the head of the house and she is to submit to him. With a broken heart, she said to me, “I finally concluded that it just wasn’t God’s will for me to be happy.” The I wanted to cry for her. The Pharisee had succeeded in stealing her joy!
But the Pharisees appear to be right. They are smug, convinced they have the law on their side. “Unlawful” and “lawful” are the key words.
What did the law say about what the disciples were doing?
Deut 23:25 “When you enter your neighbor’s standing grain, then you may pluck the heads with your hand, but you shall not wield a sickle in your neighbor’s standing grain (NAS).
It is clear that the disciples are not violating what this verse says.
But the Pharisees have another verse (they always do).
Exodus 34:21 “Six days you shall labor, but on the seventh day you shall rest; even during the plowing season and harvest you must rest.
The Rabbis took this command to rest on the Sabbath and established 39 categories of work that were forbidden. The third category was reaping. They concluded that the act of picking the grain, rubbing it in your hands to get the kernel, was the work of reaping.
I know what you think. Give me a break – that’s stupid. You can’t be serious! But Pharisees are serious! (Maybe they are stupid too!)
Why do Pharisees need to be right? A Pharisee might think the following:
· Feed my ego – It feels good to be right!
· I need control – My world is more secure if I am right.
· I fear difference – Life is easier if I don’t have to deal with diversity.
· This is what pleases God – Perhaps this is the most dangerous of all, that God is pleased by my self-rightness.
· Share my misery – I’m not happy as a Pharisee, so why should you be.
Pharisees need a deeper, perhaps even a genuine, experience of the gospel of God’s grace.
Remember that woman who concluded that it just wasn’t God’s will for her to be happy. I found out later that her Pharisee husband had an affair with his next door neighbor. I really believe that the Pharisee in us most comes out when we are not dealing with our sin and shame. Remember how Jesus describes the Pharisees as nicely painted mausoleums that are filled on the inside with dead men’s bones.
Pharisees are often saying by their judgments, “I haven’t found the joy of freedom in Christ so I want to make sure no one else does.”
Listen to how Jesus responds. He calls their attention to an instance in David’s life where he clearly broke the ritual OT law. He and his men ate bread that was dedicated to God and was reserved for the priests to eat.
Now, let’s be clear that Jesus is not teaching situation ethics where all right and wrong is determined by circumstances. At the same time we realize that not every issue of human behavior is as neatly packaged, as we’d like it to be.
Jesus suggests the Pharisees had a fundamental misconception of God’s purpose for the law. He says, “The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath.” The Pharisees would say, “God made man for the Sabbath.”
Think about that statement for a moment. Did God establish the Sabbath and then create Israel so they could become slaves to its observance, or did he establish the Sabbath as a gift of grace to his people?
Jesus and the Pharisees viewed the law through different lenses.
The Pharisees only saw, “do not commit adultery,” as a warning against the evils of sex. Jesus saw that “do not commit adultery” primarily calls us to the beauty and pleasure of a monogamous, heterosexual marriage relationship.
Did God sit down one day and say, “let’s create this wonderful thing called sex and then create humans who crave it but can’t have it?” Remember how Mark Twain lamented when “he railed against God for parceling out to each human a source of universal joy and pleasure, then forbidding it until marriage and restricting it to one person” (Leadership (Fall 1982): 33). Is God a stealer of joy?
The Pharisees only saw that, “do not steal,” warns of the wrong possession of property. Jesus saw that “do not steal” primarily emphasizes the joy, value, and beauty of possessing things. Possessions may be wrongly obtained, or become idolatrous, or be used as a means by which to enjoy God’s good gifts and glorify him.
The Pharisees allowed the abuse of something to become the lens through which they forbade the use of it.
The law’s focus is not the forbidding of pleasure but the preservation of God-honoring pleasure.
I am afraid that as evangelical Christians we have so focused on the negatives and, like the Pharisees, have added our own 39 interpretations of it, that we lose our joy and steal the joy of others.
All Christian young people know they shouldn’t fornicate or even “hook up” as they call it. But how many understand the beauty of sex that has been preserved for a monogamous heterosexual marriage relationship. They know what they shouldn’t have, but lack the faintest idea of what they should desire.
Jesus affirms that His law is alive and gives life. It is not a lifeless corpse. It is the voice of a gracious God calling those whom He loves to live fully. He also implies that ‘law’ (whether Old Covenant or New Covenant) can be and often is misapplied.
But, Jesus then says something startling to the Pharisee: So the Son of Man is Lord even of the Sabbath.
In my understanding he’s saying this: These men are walking with me and plucking grain on the Sabbath without my rebuke. However, you might interpret the Sabbath law does not matter if I say differently. Here, as in other places in the gospels, we see this transfer of authority. The law anticipated Christ. Christ fulfills the law. Christ is the new law of liberty.
He declares that all interpretation of Sabbath law is subject to Jesus Christ.
Jesus is the new and final lawgiver, better than Moses (Heb 3) who gives us the law of liberty (James 1) and the Spirit of liberty (2 Cor 3) so that we may live lives of liberty (John 8:32-34), free from the bondage of man-made legalism (Gal 5:1).
A good motto for anyone’s life is given by Paul in 1 Cor 4:6:
… not to go beyond what is written,…
Remember that Pharisee husband I mentioned. I’d like to talk to him someday (first with a baseball bat – only kidding) about how he views the law and how he views Jesus. Apparently, his relationship with Jesus is one that is miserable and consequently he makes his wife miserable. He needs a deeper experience of the gospel of grace. I would like to ask him, did Jesus die for you to make your life miserable so that you could make your wife’s life miserable? Does the truth set only you free and not your wife?
What does God offer us through faith in the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ? Does the gospel take us from pleasure in sin to misery in Jesus? Is that our picture of the Christian life? Is the gospel a judge’s gavel or the key to freedom? “If the son therefore shall make you free you will be free indeed.”
Is the gospel a choker chain or a yoke that is easy and a burden that is light? Does the gospel call us to lives that are governed by what we think the Pharisees might say? Or, does the gospel call us to the Lordship of Jesus Christ?
Instead of allowing the Pharisees to steal our joy, why not submit to the Lordship of Christ and to His will as revealed in the Bible. There we will find a comforting balance and avoid the extremes of those who deny Christ’s authority and those who deny Christian liberty.
The unbelieving world denies Christ and abuses God’s good gifts (such as food, sex, and dance, wine) while the Pharisaical world denies the pleasure of the rightful use of them. Neither abuse nor abstention is the biblical answer. Though one may personally conclude that abstention is necessary for himself because of his own personal proclivities and weaknesses, he should never conclude that his personal standard is equivalent to God’s standard.
The Bible is clear on a proper and God-honoring use of food[1], sex[2], wine[3], and dance[4], while at the same time it exposes the improper use of them (gluttony, fornication, drunkenness, idolatrous dance).
Conclusion:
We aren’t told what went through the disciples’ minds that day as they witnessed this confrontation. Certainly, they were in a quandary. On one hand they have the Pharisees who are the respected religious authority in 1st Century Palestine. On the other hand they have Jesus who questions their authority.
I suspect that when the dispute was over, they plucked some grain, placed it on their tongue, salivated with joy, and went on walking joyfully with Jesus.
Listen to Paul in Galatians 5:1:
It is for freedom that Christ has set us free. Stand firm, then, and do not let yourselves be burdened again by a yoke of slavery.
You may enjoy your dance to the glory of God, but avoid the dance of idolatry.
You may enjoy the wonderful variety of food that’s out there, but avoid gluttony.
You may enjoy the pleasure and joy of wine, but avoid drunkenness.
You may enjoy the wonder of marital sex, but avoid fornication.
I pray that all of us will consider this text and make at least two decisions:
· I will pursue joy in Christ by living in biblical freedom and will refuse to let anyone steal it.
· I will stop stealing the joy of others by holding them to expectations that are beyond the scope of clear biblical teaching.
I hope that all of us would choose a joyful walk with Jesus through the grain field even though violating the expectations of the Pharisees.
Walking with Jesus on a holy day
Plucking the grain along the way
A Heart filled with joy
A Mind that’s at peace
Until I hear the Pharisees say,
You must be wrong
You’re having fun
Those who are righteous
Don’t live in the sun
They love the shadow
They fix upon gloom
They don’t imagine
A fun-filled room
But Jesus speaks
With words so strong
“I am right and you are wrong”
I give life, and joy and peace
Freedom, love, and glad release
Follow me and you will see
I am better than the Pharisee.
And, indeed! He is!
[1] See Nehemiah 8:10; Ecclesiastes 8:15; 9:7; 1 Chronicles 12:39-40
[2] See the article on the Joy of Christian sex at http://sheilawraygregoire.com/thejoyofchristiansexp57.php.
[3] See the excellent article by Daniel Whitfield at http://chetday.com/alcoholandthebible.htm.
[4] See the reference to dance in the Bible at http://bonasdancesite.homestead.com/DanceinBible.html.